Off topic: NYT on Asian goalkeepers

2011 08 02 ali al habsi

Given my obsession with interest in soccer and goalkeeping, I would be remiss if I failed to point out a story in today’s New York Times on Asian goalkeepers.

From the lede:

Two years ago, Park Ji-sung grabbed headlines when he became the first Asian to play in a Champions League final.

Asian players like Park, a midfielder, and Atsuto Uchida, a Japanese defender with the German team Schalke 04, which United beat in the semifinals, are not the rarity they once were. They can be found playing in all positions in the major leagues of Europe, except one: goalkeeper.

That situation may be starting to change, albeit slowly.

A few thoughts:

  1. Ali Al Habsi (pictured above), of Oman and the English Premier League’s Wigan Athletic, is cited as one of the few Asian goalkeepers who is playing in one of Europe’s top leagues. And while Asian goalkeepers’ shorter height is mentioned as a factor holding some back, Al Habsi’s stature isn’t mentioned. He’s roughly 6’4″ tall, and is about as non-diminutive as you can get.
  2. I imagine that language is another a challenge. Non-English speakers playing in the outfield who can’t talk to their teammates aren’t as hindered as a goalkeeper who can’t communicate with his defenders.
  3. If memory serves, the authors of the excellent 2009 book Soccernomics ((The full title is: Soccernomics: Why England Loses, Why Germany and Brazil Win, and Why the U.S., Japan, Australia, Turkey–and Even Iraq–Are Destined to Become the Kings of the World’s Most Popular Sport.)) point out that European soccer managers are not rewarded for making unconventional decisions regarding players and managers.

    Thus, suppose a manager were to recruit a Japanese or Korean goalkeeper who has all the tools needed to succeed. If the goalkeeper fails, the manager is likely to be blamed for trying something different. Better to stick with a British or northern European goalkeeper, then, since conventional wisdom says they’re better suited to the English game. That way, if the player doesn’t pan out, the boss won’t be blamed for his crazy ideas. It will simply be the player’s fault.

  4. Great to see the 21-year-old Thai goalkeeper Kawin Thamsatchanan, who plays for Bangkok’s own Muangthong United, getting a shout out. You can see him in action in this YouTube compilation.

(Image: Ali Al-Habsi, via Wikipedia.)

3 replies on “Off topic: NYT on Asian goalkeepers”

I like to think it has more to do with skill than anything. Park has a passable level of English, but his play on the ball is superb. Are EPL and other European leagues doing a sufficient amount of scouting in Asia? But I do agree with your #2 point. Communication from the goalie is key. Here in the US, the keeper for my Philadelphia team speaks six languages, and some games I think he uses them all!

Interesting point about scouting in Asia, Josh. It’s something I’d like to investigate. And did you see that Park just signed a new contract at Man U? He has been an incredible asset for them over the years.

Interesting article but I wonder why the fixation on Asian goalkeepers? Considering that it’s the New York Times, I would have expected them to note more than the American footballers most able to hold their own in the premier European leagues tend to be goalkeepers (Tim Howard, Kasey Keller, Marcus Hahnemman, etc.) rather than outfield players. And I’m guessing that with them, it’s not just height but also ball handling skills acquired from playing basketball that are major factors…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *